An Open Letter to
Professional Tango Teachers
I have been
dancing Tango since 2002. Except for one year, I actively took lessons during
this period of 6 years until now (as of 2008). I have seen extremely talented teachers,
and some so-so ones. Today, however, I won't be talking about skills and
talents because that is not what teaching is about.
To quote Nito Garcia: "Tango does not have an official school that
grants degrees". What is considered good and what is considered bad are only
people's opinions. Most of these opinions are well-established and logical
within themselves. Still, there are a lot of points that not everybody agrees
upon. Many teachers I have seen were bold enough to know this fact and respect
it. Some others were not. Please, don't be a member of the second group. It is
extremely discouraging for a student of yours to hear your claims on how other
people are dancing like a "mess", when actually there is no universally
accepted "mess". This will just decrease your credibility. You may be making your
living out of teaching Tango (i.e. you're a "professional"), yet this does not
make you the ultimate authority. Keep in mind that your students in that class might
have been taught by other teachers, some of them you wouldn't like to compete
on a dance floor. Overreaching statements, as in every aspect of life, is not so
welcome by many tango dancers.
What I have
been talking about so far shouldn't be understood as if I want some sort of chaos
in Tango.
Examples of
perfectly valid statements are:
-
"Always
collect before pivoting"
-
"There
should be no weight on your supporting leg"
-
"You
should be facing your partner"
Examples of
not so valid statements are:
-
"You
must never do xxx on that side because it feels unnatural" (maybe it just feels
unnatural to you?)
-
"What
you just showed me is a mess because we don't do it that way"
Please
remember that this is not a high school, and your students are not your kids. Treat
them and their already established dancing styles with enough respect. If you're
a professional, then behave like one.